404 Page Design: What to Include and Examples That Work

November 16, 2026

A good 404 page tells a lost visitor what happened, looks like the rest of your site, and offers two or three clear ways forward. It is a small page, but it catches people at the moment they are most likely to leave. If you are a small business owner, a branded 404 page is one of the cheapest trust signals you can add to your website.

Charles-creative
Make Every Page Feel On Brand
Charles-creative creates custom websites and branding for small businesses, helping your 404 page fit the rest of your online presence.

Visit

TL;DR

  • A 404 page appears when a visitor requests a URL your site cannot find. Treat it as a short, helpful detour, not a dead end.
  • Include a plain-language headline, a one-sentence explanation, your main navigation, a search box or a few top links, and one clear next step.
  • Keep it on brand: same logo, fonts, colors and voice as the rest of the site. Humor is optional and should be used carefully.
  • Make sure the page still returns a real 404 status code, otherwise search engines can treat it as a normal page.
  • Fix the broken links that cause the errors. The best 404 page is one visitors rarely see.

Table of Contents

What a 404 page is and why it matters

Every page on your site has an address. When someone types one that doesn’t exist, follows an old link, or clicks a link you later deleted, your server answers with a “404 Not Found” message. Mozilla’s developer documentation explains that this status means the server cannot find the requested resource, and that common causes are mistyped URLs and pages that were moved or deleted without a redirect.

If you do nothing, visitors see a generic browser or hosting message, usually white, technical and unbranded. That page doesn’t say whose site they are on or what to do next. For a local service business, that’s a poor first or second impression. Someone who clicked a Google result for “roofing estimate” and landed on a bare error screen may simply hit Back and call the next company.

A custom 404 page fixes that. The U.S. Web Design System, the design standard for federal websites, describes the job simply: tell users the page doesn’t exist, then instruct them what to do next. Federal agencies and small shops have the same problem here, and the same answer works.

What should be on a 404 page

The U.S. Web Design System template breaks the page into six parts: a heading that describes the error, a short line on what caused it, possible ways to fix it, action buttons or links, extra support channels if you have them, and the error code in small text. That structure is a solid base for a small business site. Here it is adapted for you.

Six essential parts of a custom 404 page

A clear headline

Say what happened in plain words. “We can’t find that page” beats “Error 404: Resource not located.” Your visitor isn’t a developer and shouldn’t have to decode anything.

One sentence of explanation

Give the likely reasons without blaming the visitor: the page may have moved, the link may be out of date, or the address may have a typo. Keep it to a sentence or two.

Your normal navigation

Keep your header and main menu on the page. The U.S. Web Design System advises a consistent layout so the error page looks like your website and lets people jump to another section directly. Visitors who see your logo and menu know they are still in the right place.

A search box or a short list of top destinations

If your site has more than a handful of pages, add a search field. If it is a five-page site, a short list of links does the same job: Services, Pricing, About, Contact. Choose the pages most visitors want. For a local business, that usually means the service pages and the contact page.

One primary next step

Pick a single main button. For most small businesses it is either “Back to home” or “Get in touch.” If a visitor was clearly looking for something you offer, a contact link turns the error into a lead. Our call to action examples show wording that works on buttons like this.

A way to reach a person

A phone number or email gives stuck visitors an exit. If your contact details live on a dedicated page, link to it, and make sure that page is built well. Our guide to contact page best practices covers what to put there.

What to leave off

Skip pop-ups, newsletter forms that interrupt the visitor, long paragraphs and technical jargon. The visitor is already a bit disoriented. Smashing Magazine’s guide to optimizing error pages makes the same point: error pages should be simple and focused, because people arrive confused.

A simple layout you can follow

Here is a layout that works for a typical small business site. It fits on one screen on a phone, which matters because many visitors arrive on mobile. (Our guide to responsive web design explains why.)

Order Element Example for a local service business
1 Header with logo and menu Same as every other page
2 Headline “We couldn’t find that page”
3 Short explanation “The link may be old, or the page may have moved.”
4 Search box or top links Services, Pricing, About, Contact
5 Primary button “Back to home” or “Request a quote”
6 Contact line Phone number and email
7 Footer Same as every other page

Notice that the 404 page is built from parts your site already has. That’s deliberate. It keeps the page consistent and cheap to maintain.

404 page examples and what to borrow from them

Gallery sites and design communities collect thousands of creative error pages, and scrolling them is fun. Most are built by agencies, game studios and tech brands with illustration budgets. As a small business owner, you don’t need to copy the artwork. You need to copy the thinking. Three approaches are worth borrowing.

The helpful-products approach

An e-commerce roundup from Drip describes Urban Outfitters showing its most popular products with prices on its error page rather than sending visitors straight to the homepage, which gives shoppers a starting point. Another retailer in the same roundup makes the search bar the central feature, backed by recommended products. A service business can do the equivalent: show your three most-requested services with a link to each.

The brand-voice approach

A short, human line in your own voice does more than a cartoon. A dental office might say, “This page isn’t here, but we are.” A landscaper might say, “Looks like this path leads nowhere. Let’s get you back to the garden.” Either works if it sounds like the way you talk to customers. Smashing Magazine’s advice is to use humor wisely, since jokes can be misunderstood. If your brand is formal, stay formal.

The clean utility approach

Government and healthcare sites favor a calm page with a plain headline, a few links and a contact option. For professional services like accounting, law, contracting or medical, this is often the best fit. It looks established and doesn’t try too hard.

Whichever you choose, the test is the same: could a first-time visitor who hit a dead link find what they came for in under ten seconds?

Match the page to your brand

Yes, a 404 page can be customized. On WordPress, most themes include a 404 template, and a designer can rebuild it to match your site. On other website builders there is usually a setting for a custom error page. The page should carry the same visual identity as the rest of your site: logo, colors, type, photography style and tone.

This is where brand work pays off in small places. If your brand has clear guidelines, the 404 page practically designs itself. If it doesn’t, the error page will expose that quickly. Our guide to brand identity for small businesses explains what a consistent system includes, and our local business website checklist lists the other pages a site needs besides this one.

Get the technical side right

A beautiful 404 page can still cause problems if it’s set up wrong. Two things matter.

Return a real 404 status. Google’s documentation on soft 404 errors describes the problem: a page that tells people the content is missing but returns a 200 “success” code. Google says custom 404 pages exist for users and that the server should still send a 404 code so those pages aren’t indexed. In practice, ask your developer or hosting support to confirm that a missing URL on your site shows your custom page and returns a 404 code.

Redirect pages you moved on purpose. If you renamed or replaced a page, send the old address to the new one with a redirect. Mozilla notes that pages moved or deleted without redirection are a common cause of 404 responses. If a page is gone for good with no replacement, a 404 is the honest answer.

These two habits keep your 404 page for what it should be: a safety net for the occasional bad link, not a place visitors land every day.

Get the technical side right

Find and fix what causes the errors

The best 404 page doesn’t replace link maintenance. A short routine helps:

  1. Check after every change. When you rename a service page, rebuild a menu or launch a redesign, click through the main paths.
  2. Review Google Search Console. It reports pages Google tried and failed to find, so you can fix or redirect them.
  3. Update outside links you control. Your Google Business Profile, social bios, email signatures and directory listings should point to live pages.
  4. Watch for typos in your own links. Many broken links are internal.

A site redesign is the most common time for 404s to spike, because URLs change. If you are planning one, build the redirect list before launch. Our website redesign services page explains how we approach a redesign.

Measure what the page does

Once your 404 page is live, you can see whether it helps. Track how many visitors land on it, how many click onward, and which missing URLs come up most. If many people hit the same dead address, it needs a redirect. If few click onward, the next step may be unclear.

Smashing Magazine’s advice is to let A/B testing data decide which version works best rather than relying on opinions. For a small site, that can be as simple as running two button labels for a month and comparing clicks. This overview of a well-designed website for SEO also explains how design choices connect to the analytics you track after launch.

Our perspective

We think of the 404 page as a brand detail that tells a visitor how much care went into the rest of the site. Most small businesses never look at it. Then a customer hits a broken link and sees a gray default screen, and the business looks less established than it is.

Our approach is bespoke. We don’t drop a template into your site. We start with your business: who your visitors are, what they most often look for, and what you want them to do next. Then we build the 404 page from your own brand system, so the logo, color, type and voice match every other page.

You work directly with the creative director from start to finish, and every asset we create is fully yours, with no ongoing licensing requirements or vendor lock-in. A good 404 page is a small piece of a strategy-led website, and that’s how we treat it.

Charles

Want a 404 page that fits your brand?

If your site still shows a default error page, or you are about to redesign and want links and error handling done properly, our Web Design & Development service builds custom WordPress sites that include these details. If your current site needs a refresh, our Website Redesign service is the place to start. Tell us about your business and we will take it from there.

Charles-creative

If the 404 page is one part of a bigger question about how your business looks online, our guide to the benefits of professional website design is a good next read. You can also see how we lay out key pages in our service page layout guide.

FAQ

What does a 404 page mean?

It means the visitor’s browser reached your site, but the server could not find the page at the address requested. Typical causes are a mistyped URL, an old link, or a page that was moved or deleted. It doesn’t mean your whole site is down.

What should be on a 404 page?

Use a plain headline, a short explanation, your usual navigation, a search box or a few key links, and one clear button such as “Back to home” or “Get in touch.” Add a phone number or email if you want stuck visitors to reach you. Keep the page simple and on brand.

Can you customize a 404 page?

Yes. WordPress themes typically include a 404 template that can be redesigned, and most website platforms let you set a custom error page. The page should match your site’s logo, colors, fonts and voice, and it should still return a 404 status code.

Should a 404 page be funny?

Only if humor fits your brand. A light line works well for a bakery or a boutique. For an accountant, a clinic or a contractor, a calm, helpful message usually looks more established. Whatever tone you choose, always give visitors a clear way forward.

Sources